2019 Hall of Fame

Class of 1968
- Ron Deghi – Basketball
- Hugh Donohoe – Basketball
- Pete Povey (posthumous) – Baseball
Class of 1969
- John Bava – Soccer, Baseball
- Harry Bird – Basketball
- Gary Ittig – Basketball, Baseball
- Bob King – Basketball, Baseball
- Roger Scullion – Soccer, Baseball
Class of 1970
- John Ahlbach – Basketball
- Sam Castillo – Soccer
- Steve Cousins – Basketball, Baseball
- Pete Gosch (posthumous) – Soccer
- Bill Krueger – Soccer, Baseball
- Theo Holmes – Soccer, Track
- Don Neuner – Soccer, Baseball
- Kevin Tobin – Soccer
Class of 1971
- John Cantillon – Soccer, Baseball
- Kevin O’Connor – Soccer, Baseball
- Mike Sheehan – Soccer, Baseball
- Paul Trevisan – Soccer, Track
Class of 1972
- Mike Davis – Basketball, Baseball
- Alfredo Montelongo – Soccer
- Dan Murphy (posthumous) – Basketball, Baseball
- Vince Simpson – Basketball, Baseball
Class of 1973
- Mike Laharty – Basketball, Baseball
Class of 1974
- Bill Roonan – Soccer
- Andy Toth-Fejel – Soccer
Class of 1975
- Steve Murphy – Basketball, Soccer
Class of 1976
- John Murphy – Basketball, Soccer
Class of 1977
- Brian McAlindon – Basketball, Soccer

Record: 21-5-3
- Pat Bellomi (manager) H ‘71
- Mike Brown H ‘71
- John Buhagiar H ‘72
- John Cantillon H ‘71
- Sal Chavez H ‘71
- Charles Churchfield H ‘71
- Joe Cirimele H ’72 (posthumous)
- Charlie Clifford H ‘72
- Jim Farley H ‘72
- Mike Gard H ‘71
- Paul Hagan H ‘72
- Alfredo Montelongo H ‘72
- John Mosunic (manager) H ‘71
- Kevin O’Connor H ‘71
- Mike Sheehan H ‘71
- Dave Steacy H ‘72
- Paul Trevisan H ‘71
- John Walsh H ‘71